June 9, 2012. 127-minute dharma talk by Thich Nhat Hanh from Lower Hamlet in Plum Village during the 21-Day Retreat with the theme The Science of the Buddha. The talk is given in English and this is the sixth dharma talk (of 15).
Just prior to this session, those attending the retreat received a 86-page booklet with sutras and a Letter to a Young Scientist.
Three energies of practice
The practice of looking deeply along with a discussion of zen history. Tang Hoi, a vietnamese monk, brought zen to China. Zen. Chan. Thien. Dhyana.
Four Notions of Letting Go (from Diamond Sutra)
- Living being
- Life span
Thay spends the majority of talk teaching on self. A similar teaching is also found in Sutra #296 from Samyukta Agama.
We read from The Paramartha Gathss of Asanga Gathas on the Absolute Truth (verses 1-2)
1. There is absolutely no subject, no agent and no one who enjoys the fruit of action (no one who feels). No dharma (phenomenon, object of mind) has any function. Nonetheless the passing on of one effect to another does take place.
2. There are only the 12 limbs of existence, the aggregates, the realms (ayatanas) and the worlds (dhatus) that are always changing. When we observe thoroughly and contemplate these things we shall not find a separate self anywhere.
- Eyes (form)
- Nose (smell)
- Tongue (taste)
- Ears (sound)
- Body (touch)
- Mind (objects of mind)
There is no “self” in this. The 18 dhata includes all the twelve above plus the following:
- Eye consciousness
- Nose consciousness
- Tongue consciousness
- Ears consciousness
- Body consciousness
- Mind consciousness
Why do you think the “self” doesn’t change when everything else does?
At 1:28, Thay reads (not provided in the book) the Sutra #300 from Samyukta Agama. We continue with verse 44 from the same text above, followed by a portion of the “Discourse on the Middle Way”
44. Living beings is the name of a continuous stream and all phenomena as the object of perception are only signs. Therefore there is no real change of birth into death and death into birth and no person who realizes nirvana.
At the end of talk, Thay provides commentary on why the Buddha had to continue the practice beyond enlightenment.